Smith & Wesson Model 686 for sale
(5)
Smith & Wesson Performance Center Model 686 Competitor 6" Weighted Barrel Large .357 Mag/.38 S&W Spl +P Revolver, Matte Silver - 170319
Brand:
Smith & Wesson
Action:
Single Action
Barrel Length:
6
Caliber:
.357 Mag
Capacity:
6
Finish Per Color:
Stainless
(7)
SMITH & WESSON MODEL 686-6 PERFORMANCE CENTER
Brand:
Smith & Wesson
Action:
Double Action/Single Action
Barrel Length:
4
Caliber:
.357 Mag
Capacity:
6
Finish Per Color:
Silver Matte
Marketplace Insights
★ 4.9/5
based on 12 customer reviews across 3 variants from 19 retailers
Exceptional revolver praised for outstanding trigger quality, accuracy, and craftsmanship, with overwhelmingly positive reception and minimal cosmetic concerns.
What customers like
Trigger Quality42%
Trigger action is smooth as butter.
Accuracy & Performance42%
The most accurate handgun i own, Buy it.
Recoil Management25%
the weighted barrel reduces recoil immensely.
Craftsmanship & Finish25%
Master Craftsmanship shows in this Performance Center pistol.
Common concerns
Cylinder Aesthetics8%
the cylinder, it's plain and ugly.
Finish Durability Issues8%
three blemishes developed on the outside of every cylinder area
Frequently Asked Questions
Smith & Wesson Model 686 for sale
Is the S&W 686 worth the money?
Value depends on your needs. The 686 typically sells for $772–$1,631, with a median around $1,139. It's a well-built, reliable .357 Magnum suited for defense, hunting, and range use. Most owners consider it worth the price, but compare alternatives before buying.
How much is 686?
Smith & Wesson 686 revolvers typically cost around $1,139 based on current marketplace listings. Most listings fall between $772 and $1,631. Prices vary by barrel length, finish, and condition. We track 3 variants across 19 retailers, with 2 currently in stock.
What is the problem with the 686?
Common issues reported include cylinder binding, ejector rod loosening, and heavy trigger pull. Some users experience chamber binding or failure to fire, often linked to ammunition—particularly mixing .38 Special and .357 Magnum rounds or using soft lead bullets. Most problems are ammunition-related rather than manufacturing defects.
Can you dry fire a 686?
S&W manuals say dry firing centerfire revolvers is acceptable, but some risk of firing pin damage or firing pin hole wear exists. Many owners use snap caps to reduce that risk. If you dry fire frequently, snap caps are a worthwhile precaution.