Smith & Wesson Model 686 Plus for sale
(20)
Smith & Wesson Model 686 Plus Medium .357 Mag/.38 S&W Spl +P Revolver, Satin Stainless - 164194
Brand:
Smith & Wesson
Action:
Single Action
Barrel Length:
4
Caliber:
.357 Mag
Capacity:
7
Finish Per Color:
Stainless
(20)
Smith & Wesson Model 686 Plus .357 Magnum Revolver - 150853
Brand:
Smith & Wesson
Action:
Single Action
Barrel Length:
3
Caliber:
.357 Mag
Capacity:
7
Finish Per Color:
Stainless
(20)
Smith & Wesson Model 686 Plus .357 Mag Revolver - 164198
Brand:
Smith & Wesson
Action:
Single Action
Barrel Length:
6
Caliber:
.357 Mag/.38 S&W Special +P
Capacity:
7
Finish Per Color:
Stainless
(20)
Smith & Wesson Model 686 Plus Deluxe Small .357 Mag/.38 S&W Spl +P Revolver, Satin Stainless - 150713
Brand:
Smith & Wesson
Action:
Single Action
Barrel Length:
3
Caliber:
.357 Mag
Capacity:
7
Finish Per Color:
Stainless / Wood
Marketplace Insights
★ 4.7/5
based on 80 customer reviews across 5 variants from 18 retailers
The S&W 686 Plus is an exceptionally well-crafted revolver praised for accuracy, quality, and recoil management, with minor quality control concerns on some units.
What customers like
Accuracy & Performance45%
Very accurate and shoots well. It could stand a little polishing
Quality & Craftsmanship43%
Craftsmanship is outstanding. Totally recommend.
Recoil Management28%
The weight of the frame handles the kick when the gun fires
Trigger Quality25%
The trigger is the smoothest trigger I have ever felt.
Versatile Ammunition20%
Will shoot all configurations of 38 ammo.
Common concerns
Finish & Corrosion Issues6%
It turned black! I was able to get part of it off.
Quality Control Concerns8%
The gun has burn marks and was definitely fired.
Cosmetic/Polish Imperfections5%
The finish is not as polished as in the photo but still very nice.
Frequently Asked Questions
Smith & Wesson Model 686 Plus for sale
What makes the S&W 686 Plus special?
The 686 Plus is a seven-shot .357 Magnum revolver, offering one extra round over standard six-shot revolvers. Its stainless steel L-frame balances durability with manageable recoil, making it suitable for range use, self-defense, and hunting. It accepts moon clips for faster reloads.
What's the difference between a 686 and a 686 plus?
Standard 686 revolvers hold six rounds, while the 686 Plus chambers seven. Both fire .357 Magnum and share the same stainless L-frame design. Grip materials and barrel lengths vary by specific variant.
What hits harder, 357 or 45?
.357 Magnum generates roughly 500 ft-lbs of muzzle energy versus .45 ACP's typical 350 ft-lbs, so .357 hits harder by that measure. However, .45 delivers a slower, heavier bullet with a larger diameter. Raw energy favors .357; terminal wound channel favors .45.